Rylan survives after controversial X Factor deadlock

07:01 08 October 2012

Carolynne Poole was voted off last night

Carolynne Poole was voted off last night's show

Country singer Carolynne Poole was voted off last night’s X Factor after a tension filled elimination show saw judge Louis Walsh unable to make up his mind and go to a deadlock.

Was this the moment Louis spoke to an X Factor producer? Picture: ChescaBanks96/TwitterWas this the moment Louis spoke to an X Factor producer? Picture: ChescaBanks96/Twitter

The decision sparked controversy as a producer was seen to have spoken to Walsh moments before he made his decision.

Poole and flamboyant Rylan Clark were in the bottom two and were forced into a sing off.

Poole’s mentor Gary Barlow voted for her and even made a snide remark about Clark’s performance.

“I’m glad you learned the trick that when you pull the mic away - we don’t hear what you’re singing,” Barlow said.

Judge Nicole Scherzinger voted for Clark, who she is mentoring, while Tulisa Contostavlos said she was voting for Poole based on the night’s performance.

Walsh had the final vote and he appeared unable to make up his mind for several minutes.

“Carolynne I love country music and I love what you bring to the competition,” he said.

“Rylan you’re the entertainment factor, I love what you do.”

That left host Dermot O’Leary frustrated and he urged Walsh to hurry up and make a call.

To help keep her contestant on the show, Scherzinger was arguing her case to Walsh from the other side of the judge’s table.

“It’s entertainment, it’s the X Factor, there’s nobody else like Rylan on the show,” Scherzinger said.

After several minutes of commotion, Walsh finally said: “It’s a really difficult one. I’m going to go with Carolynne I want to keep Carolynne.”

Walsh, who appeared overwhelmed by the decision, then muttered something inaudible.

“So you’re going to send home Rylan?” O’Leary said. “Who are you sending home Louis, what did you just say?”

Unable to reaffirm that he wanted Clark out of the competition, he said: “I want to take it to deadlock.”

A deadlock means that both performers in the bottom two have an equal number of the judges’ votes and the singer with the least number of public votes will be sent home.

This led to O’Leary opening up an envelope and announcing that Poole would be leaving the competition.

Furious with the decision, Barlow got out of his chair and stormed out of the studio.

Clark, who received death threats over Twitter last week, performed Spandau Ballet’s Gold last night while wearing a gold vest and surrounded by Cleopatra dancers.

Barlow said he was “embarrassed”, and criticised the judges for keeping Clark in the competition.

But Walsh stuck up for the singer, saying: “That was amazing. I love your vocals... You’re a brilliant performer.”

Latest Stories

Yesterday, 12:44
American journalist James Foley while covering the civil war in Aleppo, Syria (AP Photo/freejamesfoley.org, Nicole Tung, File)

The SAS is closing in on the man known as ‘John’, suspected of being from London, who brutally executed US journalist James Foley.

Read more
Yesterday, 10:10
Ishak Ayiris is set to study at Eton College.  Photograph by Lucy Ray

A schoolboy who secured top marks in his GCSEs is set to follow in the footsteps of David Cameron and Boris Johnson after winning a scholarship to Eton worth £76,000.

Read more
Yesterday, 18:49
The student was caught trying to board a flight at Stansted Airport with eight flares in his luggage (Photo by Claudio Villa/Getty Images)

A student from north London was caught trying to board a plane at Stansted Airport with eight explosive flares and a terrorist manual.

Read more

Top Stories

Promotions

Advanced running and training technology for beginners up to elite athletes

If you’re thinking of adding running treadmill to your fitness routine, you’re on the right track! There are several advantages to running on a treadmill versus running outdoors.

Renault-Zoe

The Renault ZOE follows on from the introduction of the electric Fluence ZE and Twizy, but unlike the former, the ZOE was designed from the ground up as an electric vehicle.

When no simple way to find Real Ale was at hand, 4 Ale enthusiasts got together to allow anyone with a smart phone to find Real Ale no matter where they happened to be, this was the birth of the Perfect Pint app.

Quizzes

James Bond is Britain’s most famous secret agent, and the capital is its most famous city, so it makes sense that 007 would live and work here when he isn’t gallivanting around the world.

Read more
Can you find the animals hiding in London station names? (Photo by Peter Macdiarmid/Getty Images)

You may not realise it but there are animals hiding in stations across London? Play our quiz and see if you can you find them:

Read more
Can you guess the Tube station just from the outside? (Photo by Oli Scarff/Getty Images)

How well do you know your Tube stations? Can you guess these Underground stops from the pictures taken outside them?

Read more