Former schoolgirl unsuccessfully sues council after injuring her foot

09:53 17 November 2012

PA Wire/Press Association Images

A woman who sued Bromley Council after injuring her foot as a schoolgirl in Beckenham almost six years ago has failed to win damages.

Emma Richards, who was injured when a “door closed into contact with the back of her left heel”, deserved sympathy but not money after requiring five stitches, a judge said.

The Court of Appeal heard that Mrs Richards claimed damages for personal injury after the incident at Langley Park School for Girls when she was 15 in February 2007.

A county court judge had rejected Miss Richards’ claim earlier this year and three appeal judges yesterday dismissed her attempt to overturn that decision.

Lord Justice Tomlinson, who sat with Lord Justice Maurice Kay and Lord Justice Munby, said Miss Richards had suffered a “nasty laceration”.

“The injury required the insertion of five stitches at the local hospital,” said Lord Justice Tomlinson.

“She has my sympathy. Sympathy however is an insufficient basis on which to subvert the law of tort.”

He added: “It needs to be understood that not every misfortune occurring on school premises attracts compensation.”

Judges were told that another pupil at the school had suffered a “trivial injury” to her heel when the door hit her foot in October 2006.

The school’s site manager - “or more prosaically the caretaker” - had “generated a risk assessment form” and reported the step outside the door as a “hazard” following the 2006 incident, said Lord Justice Tomlinson.

He had recommended the raising of the step and work had been scheduled for Easter 2007, the judge added.

Lawyers representing Miss Richards argued that “steps could and should have been taken” following the 2006 incident to “prevent a recurrence”.

But Lord Justice Tomlinson said the arguments were “wholly unrealistic and unconvincing”.

“The trivial nature of the earlier incident and the risk which it brought to light, seen in the context of 30 years safe use of the doors by thousands of children and staff, rendered reasonable both the nature of the remedial action which the school authorities proposed to take and the timescale within which they proposed to do it,” he added.

“I would dismiss this appeal.”

Sign up for our news alerts today!

Our editors' picks for the day's top news delivered to your inbox or phone.

Sign up for email alerts Sign up for mobile alerts
1
2 3 4 5 6
7

Latest Crime news

Sunday, February 7, 2016
An 18-year-old has been charged with murder (Picture: Street View)

A teenager has been charged with murder after a 27-year-old man died from stab wounds in Plaistow Park, Newham, just over a week ago.

Friday, February 5, 2016
Nemash Patel photographed the police cordon

Thousands of commuters were evacuated from one of the city’s biggest train stations today, as a suspected World War Two bomb was found on a building site near Victoria.

Friday, February 5, 2016
George Verrier was punched when he tried to calm down a fight. He hit his head on the pavement and later died (Photo: Metropolitan Police/PA Wire

)

Two Metropolitan police officers have been dismissed for gross misconduct after the death of 17-year-old George Villiers who was punched at a party in Bromley.

Thursday, February 4, 2016
They hit him with his own cane (Photo: Christopher Furlong/Getty Images)

Police are hunting for two men responsible for a sickening attack the Grahame Park estate in Colindale.

Wednesday, February 3, 2016
Franklyn Mathurin pleaded guilty to the burglary (Photo: Metropolitan Police)

A man who stole a laptop full of family photographs of a young boy as his father was burying him has been caught and jailed.

Tuesday, February 2, 2016
A man was stabbed in Plaistow Park on Friday

A murder inquiry is underway after a man who was knifed in a fight in Newham died in hospital yesterday.

What is this?

Near You Now

Don't Miss...

Competitions

Sony Smart Ultra HD 55'' LED TV

Enjoy the ultimate entertainment experience in your living room with the Sony Smart Ultra 55’’ LED TV. Be the envy of all your friends with this huge TV- you can change your living room into your own cinema! Get the boys around to watch the football or get the girls around to watch the DVD of 50 Shades.. this is a prize that everyone would enjoy! Stand a chance to upgrade your current entertainment system by wining this fantastic prize.

Read more
Surface Pro 4

Technology is ever evolving. We are constantly being shown new technology that is innovative, revolutionary and designed to make life easier for us all. Gone are the days of dial up modems and computers so large you needed half a room to store it. We are in the age of smooth, small and sleek. Companies are all trying their best to create technology that is easy to transport and guaranteed to be user friendly.

Read more

Latest Tech News

Transport