High Speed rail scheme plunging home owners into “dire situations”

19:54 12 December 2012

A widespread housing blight caused by the HS2 high-speed rail scheme is plunging many home owners into “dire situations”, the High Court was told today.

Properties close to the proposed £32billion scheme have been devalued by between 20 per cent and 50 per cent, said David Wolfe QC.

Because of the loss of value of their homes, householders are facing an inability to move or remortgage for 15 years-plus.

The QC was appearing for campaigners who are accusing the government of carrying out a “conspicuously unfair” consultation exercise on compensation for blight before HS2 was approved last January by Justine Greening, then transport secretary.

The HS2 Action Alliance, which has more than 70 affiliated action groups and residents’ associations, claims ministers have left ordinary people “in the dark”.

The case is one of five applications for judicial review triggered by the scheme to link London and Birmingham by rail in 45 minutes.

The government says it has acted fairly and lawfully and “struck the right balance” between people’s concerns and the national interest.

Giving the scheme the go-ahead, Ms Greening said the service would create “jobs, growth and prosperity”.

Today Mr Wolfe asked Mr Justice Ouseley, sitting at the High Court in London, to rule that there must be a fresh consultation process.

Mr Wolfe told the judge the case raised the question of whether people who just happened to live and own properties close enough to the route to be affected by HS2 should have to suffer personally because of the claimed public interest in the scheme.

HS2 Ltd has contacted 172,000 households that are close, said the QC.

“A generalised blight is undoubtedly arising and (government) documents accept it.”

But the flawed two-stage consultation process under challenge left consultees without sufficient detail to understand or respond in a meaningful way. There had been overall unfairness.

Mr Wolfe argued that consultees had a legitimate expectation that a scheme would be adopted that would fairly compensate all individuals on whom “the national interest had imposed a financial loss”.

Richard Stein, from Leigh Day & Co, solicitor for the alliance, said before the hearing: “This is not a Nimby argument.

“The consequence of the government’s compensation scheme is that many thousands of people living along the route will not be able to sell their homes for some 15 years because their homes are blighted.

“If it is decided that it is in the national interest to have HS2, which our clients don’t accept, at least they should not have to bear the burden for this national project.

“Proper arrangements must be put in place if HS2 is to go ahead to make it possible for these people to move if and when they wish in the same way that the rest of us can.

“The cost of a scheme which would make this possible must be included as a part of the cost of HS2.

“The process by which the government has adopted its proposed compensation scheme has been unfair and shambolic.”

The hearing is continuing.

Sign up for our news alerts today!

Our editors' picks for the day's top news delivered to your inbox or phone.

Sign up for email alerts Sign up for mobile alerts
1
2 3 4 5 6
7

Latest Crime news

Friday, March 6, 2015
The man was seen with a knife on the Central Line before moving onto the Jubilee Line (Photo by Oli Scarff/Getty Images)

The Jubilee line was brought to a standstill today after passengers reported seeing a man carrying a knife.

Friday, March 6, 2015
The sickening attack took place near this spot on a busy main road [Image from Google StreetView]

Police believe at least two people walked by a woman being sexually assaulted on a busy road in Hounslow.

Friday, March 6, 2015
The dentist tried to fit a bridge in the Cannon Styreet branch of McDonald's (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)

A rogue dentist who tried to fit a bridge on a woman’s teeth in a branch on McDonald’s in central London has been struck off ‘for public protection’.

Friday, March 6, 2015
The attack took place on a 134 bus in Muswell Hill around 11pm on Thursday, February 12 (Picture: Met Police)

A passenger on a bus in north London was subjected to a horrific unprovoked attack after a man assaulted him from behind.

Friday, March 6, 2015
Teen victim Alan Cartwright

Two people arrested on suspicion of the murder of teenager Alan Cartwright who was stabbed to death while riding a bike in Islington have been released on bail.

Friday, March 6, 2015
Three men chased the victim in Pymmes Park, Edmonton (Pic: Google)

A 26-year-old man is in hospital after a vicious stabbing in Pymmes Park, Edmonton.

Latest Stories from SNAP.PA

The Cinderella stars were surprise guests at the film’s screening at Disneyland.

Read more

Soap fans want Michelle Ryan’s character back in Albert Square.

Read more

Creator Chuck Lorre used his hit comedy show credits to remember the late Star Trek actor.

Read more

Promoted content

A look at one of our previous Design Fairs

Chelsea Old Town Hall will be the venue for the renowned Desire Fair from 6-8 March 2015. This stunning mixed media jewellery and silversmithing event where visitors can purchase direct from contemporary designer makers selected from the best in the UK is an event not to be missed.

Take our quiz and find out!

A survey conducted last year revealed that Britain is the fourth sexiest country in the world, with the UK sex toy industry worth an estimated £250 million a year.

What is this?

Near You Now

Don't Miss...

Thousands of people have signed a petition urging Facebook to remove the ‘fat’ and ‘ugly’ emoticon options.

#TheDress features in a poignant Salvation Army campaign against domestic violence.

Quirky London