Humanists fail in Richmond faith school legal battle

08:51 17 November 2012

Opponents argued the school will not be inclusive. File picture: PA Wire/Chris Radburn

Opponents argued the school will not be inclusive. File picture: PA Wire/Chris Radburn

PA Wire/Press Association Images

Parents and members of the British Humanist Association (BHA) have failed in a High Court bid to block proposals for two new Catholic schools in Twickenham.

They had aimed to overturn Richmond council’s decision to offer the Catholic Diocese of Westminster a site in Clifden Road.

The parents come from different backgrounds and say all new state schools in Richmond should have admissions policies that are religiously inclusive.

But Mr Justice Sales, sitting in London, rejected their application for judicial review and said he would give his full reasons at a later date.

The judge upheld Richmond Council’s argument that it did not misdirect itself or act unlawfully over the faith schools.

Andrew Copson, chief executive of the BHA, said later: “We are disappointed, but once we see the full reasons for this judgment we will appeal if we possibly can.

“Today’s case hinged on very technical issues but it raises wider questions relating to religious schools.”

BHA launched its legal action jointly with the Richmond Inclusive Schools Campaign (RISC).

Last year more than 3,300 local people supported a RISC petition to the council objecting to faith schools that were exclusive and calling for all new borough schools to be inclusive.

But the council voted to buy the land for £8.4 million and invite the Catholic Diocese of Westminster to submit proposals for two “voluntary-aided” Catholic schools.

In May, the council decided to lease the Clifden Road land for educational purposes to the Diocese for a peppercorn rent.

David Wolfe QC, representing both BHA and RISC, told the High Court the new primary school would, if oversubscribed, give priority to Catholic pupils when allocating all but 10 of its 30 places a year.

The secondary school would initially give priority to Catholics in all of its 150 places a year, although making exceptions for applicants coming from the 10 “community” places at the primary school.

After seven years, 93 per cent of its places were expected to be allotted on the basis of religion.

Mr Wolfe argued that the council had breached its statutory obligation under section 6A of the 2006 Education and Inspections Act to take steps to seek proposals setting up an academy school offering more non-religious places.

He told Mr Justice Sales that the council conducted a flawed consultation exercise and had sought to bypass its statutory duty.

Disagreeing, the judge said “section 6A does not apply in the circumstances” and he was satisfied that the consultation exercise was lawful.

Today’s ruling could have important general implications as it is in effect a test case on changes to education law introduced by the Government earlier this year.

It is also believed to be the first legal challenge to the opening of new faith schools.

The judge also rejected the claim that the council had conducted a legally flawed consultation.

He ruled it had not been misleading, defective or unlawful.

Related articles

Sign up for our news alerts today!

Our editors' picks for the day's top news delivered to your inbox or phone.

Sign up for email alerts Sign up for mobile alerts
1
2 3 4 5 6
7

Latest Crime news

Friday, July 3, 2015
Hordes of police were sent in tot control the situation (Photo: @mansfieldmaddie, used with permission)

Police were called to a huge brawl in Shooters Hill last night after a party got out of hand.

Friday, July 3, 2015
Do you recognise this man? If so, please contact British Transport Police on the number listed below

Police are looking for a rugby fan after a woman was inappropriately touched after the official Army vs Navy rugby match on Saturday May 9.

Friday, July 3, 2015
Police cordon on Southwark Street junction with Blackfriars Road (Picture: Chris Kenyon)

A woman prison custody officer who was allegedly assaulted as she escorted a prisoner at Blackfriars Crown Court on Monday has died.

Friday, July 3, 2015
A later Premier League match between Everton and Tottenham Hotspur at Goodison Park on May 24 (Photo: Chris Brunskill/Getty Images)

Six males, including a 15-year-old boy, were arrested in a series of swoops across Liverpool, the Wirral and Warrington yesterday after a violent attack outside a pub on Islington’s Caledonian Road.

Friday, July 3, 2015
Police would like to speak to this woman

A Footlocker shop worker was sprayed in the face with bleach in a vicious attack in Kilburn, west London.

Thursday, July 2, 2015
Missing: Shaheed Forde-Bryan (Picture: Met Police)

Shaheed Forde-Bryan from Rainham, east London has not been home since Sunday June 14 and police are appealing for help to locate him.

What is this?

Near You Now

Don't Miss...

Competitions

Good times with Greenall's!

Good times with Greenall’s, a Great British gin sponsors Great British racing.

Read more
Escape to the picturesque sights of Cornwall

Summer is finally here, and what is the number one holiday location in the UK during the warmer months? Cornwall, of course!

Read more
Adrenalin junkies, this one's for you!

An icon of British engineering and a consistent favourite of James Bond, there are few names quite as legendary in motoring as Aston Martin.

Read more