Black woman sues police over Stop and Search that ‘breached human rights’

07:35 04 May 2012

Zeeshan Choudhary was killed in June last year

Zeeshan Choudhary was killed in June last year

Archant

A London woman has gone to the High Court over a stop and search by police officers which she claims breached her human rights.

Ann Juliette Roberts, 38, from Edmonton in north London, also claimed black people were unfairly targeted under the measure.

A special needs assistant who works with children, Mrs Roberts was detained by police following a stop and search in September, 2010.

Police officers claimed the part of Haringey she was in at the time, was a “hotspot” for gang violence and knife possession.

A struggle followed when Mrs Robert, who has an African Caribbean background, called for the search to take place not in public, but at a police station.

She was restrained face down on the ground and handcuffed. Bank cards were found in her bag in three different identities - which she said were her maiden name, married name and the name of her son.

Officers arrested her on suspicion of fraud and she was taken to Tottenham police station. Meanwhile, officers searched her home.

That charge of fraud was later dropped and Mrs Roberts was eventually issued with a caution.

At the High Court yesterday (Wednesday), Hugh Southey QC, appearing for Mrs Roberts, told two judges: “This power is used in a disproportionate way against black people, and black people in London in particular.

“We say there are no adequate explanations for that.”

Mr Southey argued stop and search powers to search without reasonable suspicion were breached European Human Rights.

He argued the “disproportionate” use of section 60 searches against black Londoners breached Article 14, which protects against discrimination.

Between 2009-2010, 43,219 black people were searched by Met officers under section 60, compared with 27,217 white people.

Mr Southey said that implied “that a black Londoner is over nine times more likely to be searched under section 60 than a white person”.

The case continues.

Latest Stories

17:53
Eliott Diffley

A data stick full of child porn fell out of a pervert’s bottom in Islington Police Station.

Read more
The most sureal moment at the Commonwealth Opening Ceremony was the sight of some giant dancing Tunnocks tea cakes (Photo by Jeff J Mitchell/Getty Images)

Did you watch the Commonwealth Games opening ceremony last night? It made us misty-eyed for London 2012, when the whole world was watching our city, so we decided to compare Glasgow 2014 to Danny Boyle’s opening ceremony. Be prepared for a blast from the past!

Read more
The Eid al-Fitr party in Trafalgar Square promises to be fun, fantastic, and free! (Photo by Daniel Berehulak/Getty Images)

Check out our five-minute guide to celebrating the end of Ramadan in London.

Read more

Quirky London

Quizzes

How much do you really know about QPR legends like Les Ferdinand? Picture: Neal Simpson/EMPICS Sport

Test your knowledge of QPR’s greatest players with our fantastic legends quiz.

Read more
How much do you know about films in London? (Photo by Fox Photos/Getty Images)

Do you know your Lock Stock from your Long Good Friday, Sliding Doors from Shakespeare in Love?

Read more
How much about this great city do you really know? Take our true Londoner quiz and find out (Photo by Matt Cardy/Getty Images)

Do you know your apples from your pears? Take our Cockney quiz and see how much of a Londoner you really are.

Read more
Guess the manager quiz. Here's a hint, it's not these four.

The managerial merry-go-round spins quickly these days so do you think you’ve got the knowledge to recognise the faces of all these football bosses?

Read more
A normal day at London Liverpool Street station

This quiz is for people who think they know the Tube and rail inside out.

Read more