High Court verdict on Brent library closures reserved until next month

13:12 22 July 2011

Brent Council

Brent Council's plans to axe six libraries is being challenged in the High Court this week

Archant

Judge will make his ruling on August 12

The verdict on a judicial review into Brent Council’s decision to axe half of the libraries in the borough will be announced next month.

In the first case in the country, campaigners fighting the library closures have taken the case to the High Court claiming the plans were ‘unlawful’.

Despite a consultation showing 82 per cent of respondents were against the plans the reading rooms in Barham Park, Cricklewood, Kensal Rise, Neasden, Preston and Tokyngton are to close.

For the last few days, Mr Justice Duncan Ouseley has been listening to evidence including claims the closures could lead to indirect discrimination against ethnic groups, the elderly and disabled.

Helen Mountfield QC, who is representing three Brent library users, said none of the groups stood a chance because their business plans resulted in some cost to the council, which the council viewed as not viable.

Criticizing the council’s decision to turn down all of the community group’s proposals to run the libraries she said they had not been given enough information about the criteria which needed to be met.

She added: “If this criteria had been disclosed then they would have been able to address the criteria. It might have made a difference to what the council thought.”

She also said the consultation was flawed as “people were not given enough information’’.

In defence, the barrister representing the council argued: “This isn’t a case of closing libraries because the council couldn’t afford to run them. It has always been about improving the library service.”

The campaign to save the six branches has seen the backing of a host of stars including musician Nick Cave, boy band JLS, playwright Alan Bennett as well as Depeche Mode and The Pet Shop Boys.

The controversial plans will save the council £1million.

The verdict is expected to be announced on August 12.

Latest Stories from SNAP.PA

If you’re a football fan, you remember it. Now Kieron Dyer has let us know exactly why Bowyer turned on him that day.

Read more

Dominican-born designer captivated the world with stunning creations.

Read more

Lady Gaga read out a fan’s emotional letter on stage, before dedicating two songs to his late mother.

Read more

Promotions

AGA Living Subscription

Every issue of AGA Living magazine is packed full of celebrity AGA owner interviews, interior and design features, ideas to inspire your culinary imagination, mouth-watering recipes and inspirational shopping ideas.

Dojo gives you hand picked recommendations for events, places and activities in London

Tired of always hearing about some amazing event in London after its gone, missing out on the best activities? That’s where Dojo comes in.

A woman has died after being hit by a tree that fell into a road as the remnants of Hurricane Gonzalo brought high winds to Britain. The pedestrian died at the scene in Kensington, west London, London Ambulance Service said. A spokeswoman said: “We were called at 11.40am to reports of a tree fallen on […]

It was one of the big innovations from Apple’s iPhone event back in September and now it’s arrived in the US.

Yet his artwork has already been vandalised in hours.

Bus driver dishes out quick punishment to would-be thief who tries to steal a passenger’s bag.

TOP Stories

4 minutes ago
Cheryl Evans, with a picture of her murdered son, Warren

The distraught mother of teenager who was stabbed to death almost a decade ago is appealing for witnesses to help find his killer.

40 minutes ago
@OccupyLondon took this photograph of London Assembly member Baroness Jenny Jones being arrested in Parliament Square.

Fifteen protesters have been arrested in Parliament Square as part of the Occupy Parliament demonstrations – including the Green Party peer Baroness Jones, who was promptly un-arrested once officers realised who she was!

58 minutes ago
Police want to talk to this man in connection with the incident (Pic: BTP)

A cannabis-smoking thug held a knife against a train passenger’s face after he was asked to extinguish his spliff.

London Bloggers

Wednesday, September 17, 2014
The cast, including Josie Lawrence and Mike Myers

Simon Collins catches up with the improv impresarios, who despite being the world’s longest-running comedy show with the same cast, have lost none of the razor-sharp wit:

Monday, September 1, 2014
Do you really need an explanation for that?! (Pic by Serena Marinelli)

If you’ve ever seen an Italian movie, you would probably know how important body language is in the culture.

Tuesday, August 26, 2014
Don't waste any of your harvest

If you are now inundated with ripe tomatoes, juicy green beans, berries and herbs, don’t leave them to go stringy or mouldy because the freezer can go a long way to making your crops last well into winter.