Judge urged to overturn ‘unlawful’ changes to Lewisham hospital

14:09 02 July 2013

Campaigners outside the Royal Courts of Justice. Activists argue the changes will mean local people would have to travel a long way further to get access to vital services. Picture: Simon Way/PA Wire

Campaigners outside the Royal Courts of Justice. Activists argue the changes will mean local people would have to travel a long way further to get access to vital services. Picture: Simon Way/PA Wire

A High Court judge has been urged to overturn an ‘unlawful’ decision to reduce services at Lewisham hospital today.

Picture: Simon Way/PA WirePicture: Simon Way/PA Wire

Campaigners packed the courtroom where Mr Justice Silber is being asked to rule on two legal challenges against cuts at the south-east London facility.

Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt told MPs in January that accident and emergency and maternity services at the hospital will be downgraded.

The London Borough of Lewisham and the Save Lewisham Hospital Campaign argue the decision to cut some of the hospital’s services was ‘unlawful’ and should be quashed.

Opponents say that if the decision is implemented it would result in ‘substantial’ cuts to the services provided by Lewisham Healthcare NHS Trust at the hospital.

The demonstration led by Save Lewisham Hospital last NovemberThe demonstration led by Save Lewisham Hospital last November

Elisabeth Laing QC, for the council, told the judge at this morning’s hearing Lewisham was a ‘very good hospital’ and the range of health services provided there was ‘greatly valued by local people and by the council’.

She said the changes would mean local people would have to travel a long, long way further to get access to vital services.

The proposed changes are part of a wider shake-up of services in the capital after the financial collapse of neighbouring South London Healthcare NHS Trust, which went into administration after it started losing more than £1million a week.

Mr Hunt told MPs the changes would improve patient care in south London, saving up to 100 lives a year.

Mr Justice Silber indicated that because of the importance of the case he would be reserving his judgment at the conclusion of the three-day hearing, and would announce his decision later in a written ruling.

Sign up for our news alerts today!

Our editors' picks for the day's top news delivered to your inbox or phone.

Sign up for email alerts Sign up for mobile alerts
1
2 3 4 5 6
7

Latest London Health news

Pete Oliver

A ‘flesh-eating virus’ has killed a Muswell Hill man after he was bitten by an insect while gardening at home.

Irmgard Cooper with her daughter Lorraine Booker

A spelling mistake and a mix-up by senior medics led to a grandmother bleeding to death after an operation at a north London hospital.

Tanya Monkman suffered a rare migraines which left unable to go out without her wheelchair. Photo: Paul Bennett

A mother of three is trying to recover her mobility after a rare migraine caused stroke-like symptoms leaving her temporarily paralysed.

The Lewisham and Greenwich NHS choir could make it to no.1 in the charts this Christmas (Picture: YouTube/LGNHS Choir)

The Christmas Number 1 2015 winner could be a south-east London NHS choir as their mash-up, ‘A Bridge Over You’, is currently rocketing up the charts.

Surprisingly dangerous (Photo: Alan Crowhurst/Getty Images)

A Londoner needed an emergency operation when he popped a champagne bottle - only for the cork to smash his glasses into his eye.

(Picture: PA)

Do these pictures give you toothache? Food artist Jacqui Kelly created sculptures by the Houses of Parliament today of a young girl, a teenage boy and an man entirely carved from sugar.

A doctor wears a badge next to her stethoscope in support of the Junior Doctor's contract (Picture: PA Images)

Today’s planned junior doctor strikes have been cancelled.

The card that was handed to Kara Florish on the Tube

This is the hateful card that was given to Kara Florish as she travelled on the Tube.

The National Health Singers in action outside St Paul's Cathedral on Saturday (Picture: Dr Georgina Wood)

Ahead of the junior doctor strike on December 1, a choir of talented medics stood in Tube stations and outside London landmarks ‘singing for survival’ with their new song to the NHS, ‘Yours’.

The Chief Inspector of Hospitals has recommended the London Ambulance Service NHS Trust is placed into special measures (Picture: PA Images)

Health watchdog CQC has said the London Ambulance Service (LAS) NHS Trust should be placed into special measures as it is ‘performing poorly’ and has been rated ‘inadequate’.

Junior doctors held a massive protest in London last month over the contracts and now plan to strike for three days in December (Picture: Naomi Ackerman/ London24)

Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt today agreed to negotiate the junior doctor contract with the British Medical Association (BMA) in talks held by conciliatory service Acas, but the BMA say his consenting so late is ‘political game playing’.

Junior doctors held a massive protest in London last month over the contracts and now plan to strike for three days in December (Picture: Naomi Ackerman/ London24)

London medics will join junior doctors nationwide in a ‘full walkout’ December 8 and 16 and offer only emergency care on December 1 after 98 per cent voted in favour of industrial action, the BMA said today.

The strikes will take place over three days in December (Picture: PA Images)

A ballot is due to close that could lead to tens of thousands of junior doctors going on an “all-out” strike in London for the first time ever.

Junior doctors held a massive protest in London last month over the contracts and now plan to strike for three days in December (Picture: Naomi Ackerman/ London24)

London medics will join junior doctors nationwide in a ‘full walkout’ December 8 and 16 and offer only emergency care on December 1, subject to final ballot, the British Medical Association (BMA) announced today.

There is a secret to a better sex life (Picture: PA Images)

How do you have better sex? The internet offers a million answers to this vital question every day, but a new study says there is one simple thing you need to do to ‘enjoy more frequent and satisfying sex for both partners’.

Cow & Gate baby muesli had a different type of natural ingredient inside

A shocked Mum found ‘a spiders web’ and ‘a maggot’ in her child’s baby muesli last week and its maker Cow & Gate are now warning parents not to give the cereal to their kids.

Anyone with information about 'spice' should call 101 (Picture: Getty)

Three men have are in hospital after taking a drug called ‘spice’ on the streets of Peckham yesterday.

A large group marched across Westminster Bridge to raise awareness

Commuters were confused this morning as ‘patients’ dressed in full hospital gear marched through central London at rush hour in an attempt to raise awareness about a lack of organ donors.

Pauline Cafferkey as she was discharged from the Royal Free in January

A Scottish nurse being treated at the Royal Free Hospital for a late complication of the Ebola virus is no longer in critical condition, the team treating her has said.

The Royal Free Hospital in Hampstead where British nurse Pauline Cafferkey is being treated (Photo: Yui Mok/PA Wire)

A Scottish nurse who was airlifted to the Royal Free Hospital in Hampstead last week for a late complication of the Ebola she contracted last year is now ‘critically ill’, the hospital has said.

The Royal Free Hospital in Hampstead where British nurse Pauline Cafferkey is being treated (Photo: Yui Mok/PA Wire)

An Ebola nurse is in an isolation ward at the Royal Free Hospital with the disease - for the second time.

It is thought Mr Hogg was bitten by a brown recluse spider

The graphic images further down this article show the catastrophic injury caused to a Camden holidaymaker’s leg from a flesh-eating spider bite.

A new study by London South Bank University shows that we do not think fat people commit crime - and it might be getting in the way of justice? (Picture: PA Images)

New London university research shows that many of us think overweight people are unlikely to commit crimes and it could be ‘getting in the way of justice’.

None of the pupils at Villiers High School required hospital treatment after the incident (Photo: Google StreetView)

London Ambulance Service were called to Villiers High School in Southall today when potentially hazardous chlorine gas was accidentally released during a science lesson.

Marina Williamson almost had a heart attack after suffering a sever reaction to PPD in her hair dye

A Wembley lawyer who had a near-fatal allergic reaction to her hair dye is urging people to sign a petition calling for a ban on a dangerous chemical.

What is this?

Near You Now

Don't Miss...

Competitions

Sony Smart Ultra HD 55'' LED TV

Enjoy the ultimate entertainment experience in your living room with the Sony Smart Ultra 55’’ LED TV. Be the envy of all your friends with this huge TV- you can change your living room into your own cinema! Get the boys around to watch the football or get the girls around to watch the DVD of 50 Shades.. this is a prize that everyone would enjoy! Stand a chance to upgrade your current entertainment system by wining this fantastic prize.

Read more
Surface Pro 4

Technology is ever evolving. We are constantly being shown new technology that is innovative, revolutionary and designed to make life easier for us all. Gone are the days of dial up modems and computers so large you needed half a room to store it. We are in the age of smooth, small and sleek. Companies are all trying their best to create technology that is easy to transport and guaranteed to be user friendly.

Read more

Latest Tech News

Transport