Lewisham A&E closure proposals ‘unsafe, rushed and unjust’

13:59 08 January 2013

Matthew Kershaw

Matthew Kershaw's recommendations came at the end of a six-week consultation. Picture: Yui Mok/PA Wire

Plans to close and downgrade Lewisham’s emergency and maternity services are “a travesty”, according to one of its consultants.

The hospital will be stripped of its A&E department under proposals today to restructure healthcare services in south east London.

Special administrator Matthew Kershaw today proposed the South London Healthcare NHS Trust is broken up after it racked up debts of £150million.

He recommended A&E services in south east London should only be provided at King’s College Hospital, St Thomas’ Hospital, Queen Elizabeth Hospital and Princess Royal University Hospital.

But Lewisham Hospital is not part of the South London Healthcare NHS Trust.

Consultant physician Dr John O’Donohue said Mr Kershaw had ignored the views of patients and health experts during his six-week consultation.

He said: “Lewisham Hospital is a solvent, successful hospital with a track record for delivering high-quality care.

“This is the first time the government has put in place its ‘Unsustainable Provider Regime’ for failing NHS organizations, and it sets a disturbing precedent.

“If services at a successful and well run hospital like Lewisham are closed due to problems at a neighbouring Trust, then no hospital in London, or the country, is safe.

“These plans are a travesty. They are unsafe, rushed and unjust, but most of all will disadvantage the people of Lewisham, who will have to travel further to already overcrowded neighbouring A&E and maternity units – units which, ironically, have themselves been diverting ambulances and pregnant women to Lewisham in recent days due to lack of capacity.”

Around 15,000 people took part in a march last November to protest against the threat to Lewisham’s A&E unit in November. A further demonstration will take place from the Lewisham Roundabout from noon on January 26.

“No viable alternative option”

The Lewisham Healthcare NHS Trust consultants, and GPs commissioning group also opposed the recommendations.

Lewisham East MP Heidi Alexander also delivered a petition, signed by more than 32,000 people opposing the recommendations, to Downing Street.

A spokesman for the Lewisham Healthcare NHS Trust said they were grateful for the support they had received.

He said: “We do support merging with Queen Elizabeth, which is one of the recommendations.

“However, we do not agree with the TSA’s prescriptive approach to service change, which would result in local emergency services being closed and maternity services being downgraded.

“As a successful organisation, we have said we would like to determine the future of services ourselves, and we would include proper engagement with stakeholders and the public.

He added: “All our services are continuing to run as normal. If the Health Secretary does decide to make changes, it would take place over a three year period, and alternative arrangements would have to be in place first.”

A spokesman for Mr Kershaw said: “The views of local doctors have been extremely important and the trust special administrator (TSA) has sought to modify his recommendations where possible on the basis of clinical feedback.

The challenge was that no viable alternative option was presented.

“To be clear, the consultation was not a vote on whether the recommendations should proceed but an opportunity to validate and refine the options set out in the draft recommendations.

As the TSA has consistently stated, doing nothing is not an option.”

Related articles

Latest Stories

Yesterday, 12:50
The man fell from the top floor penthouse above Barclays Bank in West Hampstead (Picture via Google StreetView)

A man who reportedly fell to his death from a penthouse in Hampstead while naked has been indentified as a Harley Street doctor who ran a Botox clinic.

Read more
Yesterday, 18:10
Police are advising members of the public not to approach John McClintock and contact officers immediately if they see him (Picture: Metropolitan Police)

Police are appealing for the public’s help in tracing a 26-year-old man who absconded from a bail hostel in Richmond yesterday.

Read more
Yesterday, 17:17
The Isufi family, from left back, mum Meri, daughter Ramela, dad Erion, son Richard and youngest son Clive (front)

A vast gathering of friends and neighbours stood outside the Barking home of a family torn apart by a car crash to pay their tributes to them today.

Read more

TOP Stories

Yesterday, 12:50
The man fell from the top floor penthouse above Barclays Bank in West Hampstead (Picture via Google StreetView)

A man who reportedly fell to his death from a penthouse in Hampstead while naked has been indentified as a Harley Street doctor who ran a Botox clinic.

Yesterday, 18:10
Police are advising members of the public not to approach John McClintock and contact officers immediately if they see him (Picture: Metropolitan Police)

Police are appealing for the public’s help in tracing a 26-year-old man who absconded from a bail hostel in Richmond yesterday.

Yesterday, 17:17
The Isufi family, from left back, mum Meri, daughter Ramela, dad Erion, son Richard and youngest son Clive (front)

A vast gathering of friends and neighbours stood outside the Barking home of a family torn apart by a car crash to pay their tributes to them today.

Promotions

Renault-Zoe

The Renault ZOE follows on from the introduction of the electric Fluence ZE and Twizy, but unlike the former, the Zoe was designed from the ground up as an electric vehicle.

When no simple way to find Real Ale was at hand, 4 Ale enthusiasts got together to allow anyone with a smart phone to find Real Ale no matter where they happened to be, this was the birth of the Perfect Pint app.

London24 have partnered up with The Week magazine to offer you a complimentary issue – delivered free to your door.

London Bloggers

Thursday, July 24, 2014
London comedians are preparing for Edinburgh (Photo by Jeff J Mitchell/Getty Images)

During these sultry July afternoons and endless balmy evenings the nervous musings of young comedians in London drift to dreams of triumph on the Edinburgh stage.

Thursday, July 24, 2014
Punchdrunk's The Drowned Man poduction came to an end on Sunday, July 6

If you’ve been wandering around bereft of purpose, a wet-eyed stare fixed on your blank face, then no doubt you too are as gutted as I am that The Drowned Man has finally come to an end.

Thursday, July 24, 2014
(Photo by Joern Pollex/Getty Images)

We’ve been called P.I.G.S.

Quizzes

But which London?! [Photo courtesy of Basher Eyre]

You might know London like the back of your hand, but how well do you know the other Londons - and London landmarks - across the world?

Read more
The prize is glory (Photo by Dan Kitwood/Getty Images)

It used to be Manhattan that was famous for its majestic skyline, but now our fair city is catching up. Do you know your Shard from your Heron Tower?

Read more
Test your London musical knowledge with our album quiz (Images via Getty)

Does your music knowledge stretch from The Rolling Stones to Rudimental, Spandau Ballet to Siouxsie and the Banshees? If so then test it out with our London bands quiz:

Read more