Lewisham A&E closure proposals ‘unsafe, rushed and unjust’

13:59 08 January 2013

Matthew Kershaw

Matthew Kershaw's recommendations came at the end of a six-week consultation. Picture: Yui Mok/PA Wire

Plans to close and downgrade Lewisham’s emergency and maternity services are “a travesty”, according to one of its consultants.

The hospital will be stripped of its A&E department under proposals today to restructure healthcare services in south east London.

Special administrator Matthew Kershaw today proposed the South London Healthcare NHS Trust is broken up after it racked up debts of £150million.

He recommended A&E services in south east London should only be provided at King’s College Hospital, St Thomas’ Hospital, Queen Elizabeth Hospital and Princess Royal University Hospital.

But Lewisham Hospital is not part of the South London Healthcare NHS Trust.

Consultant physician Dr John O’Donohue said Mr Kershaw had ignored the views of patients and health experts during his six-week consultation.

He said: “Lewisham Hospital is a solvent, successful hospital with a track record for delivering high-quality care.

“This is the first time the government has put in place its ‘Unsustainable Provider Regime’ for failing NHS organizations, and it sets a disturbing precedent.

“If services at a successful and well run hospital like Lewisham are closed due to problems at a neighbouring Trust, then no hospital in London, or the country, is safe.

“These plans are a travesty. They are unsafe, rushed and unjust, but most of all will disadvantage the people of Lewisham, who will have to travel further to already overcrowded neighbouring A&E and maternity units – units which, ironically, have themselves been diverting ambulances and pregnant women to Lewisham in recent days due to lack of capacity.”

Around 15,000 people took part in a march last November to protest against the threat to Lewisham’s A&E unit in November. A further demonstration will take place from the Lewisham Roundabout from noon on January 26.

“No viable alternative option”

The Lewisham Healthcare NHS Trust consultants, and GPs commissioning group also opposed the recommendations.

Lewisham East MP Heidi Alexander also delivered a petition, signed by more than 32,000 people opposing the recommendations, to Downing Street.

A spokesman for the Lewisham Healthcare NHS Trust said they were grateful for the support they had received.

He said: “We do support merging with Queen Elizabeth, which is one of the recommendations.

“However, we do not agree with the TSA’s prescriptive approach to service change, which would result in local emergency services being closed and maternity services being downgraded.

“As a successful organisation, we have said we would like to determine the future of services ourselves, and we would include proper engagement with stakeholders and the public.

He added: “All our services are continuing to run as normal. If the Health Secretary does decide to make changes, it would take place over a three year period, and alternative arrangements would have to be in place first.”

A spokesman for Mr Kershaw said: “The views of local doctors have been extremely important and the trust special administrator (TSA) has sought to modify his recommendations where possible on the basis of clinical feedback.

The challenge was that no viable alternative option was presented.

“To be clear, the consultation was not a vote on whether the recommendations should proceed but an opportunity to validate and refine the options set out in the draft recommendations.

As the TSA has consistently stated, doing nothing is not an option.”

Related articles

Sign up for our news alerts today!

Our editors' picks for the day's top news delivered to your inbox or phone.

Sign up for email alerts Sign up for mobile alerts
2 3 4 5 6

Latest London Health news

The Royal Free Hospital in Hampstead where British nurse Pauline Cafferkey is being treated (Photo: Yui Mok/PA Wire)

An Ebola nurse is in an isolation ward at the Royal Free Hospital with the disease - for the second time.

It is thought Mr Hogg was bitten by a brown recluse spider

The graphic images further down this article show the catastrophic injury caused to a Camden holidaymaker’s leg from a flesh-eating spider bite.

A new study by London South Bank University shows that we do not think fat people commit crime - and it might be getting in the way of justice? (Picture: PA Images)

New London university research shows that many of us think overweight people are unlikely to commit crimes and it could be ‘getting in the way of justice’.

None of the pupils at Villiers High School required hospital treatment after the incident (Photo: Google StreetView)

London Ambulance Service were called to Villiers High School in Southall today when potentially hazardous chlorine gas was accidentally released during a science lesson.

Marina Williamson almost had a heart attack after suffering a sever reaction to PPD in her hair dye

A Wembley lawyer who had a near-fatal allergic reaction to her hair dye is urging people to sign a petition calling for a ban on a dangerous chemical.

The sexual health clinic on Dean Street mistakenly sent out sensitive data  (Photo: Carl Court/Getty Images)

A major London sexual health centre mistakenly revealed the email addresses of almost 800 HIV clinic patients yesterday - and could be facing a fine of half a million pounds for the “hugely invasive breach of privacy”.

Polish people are donating blood to say thank you for the opportunities they have  to work and study in the UK (Photo: Tim Boyle/Getty Images)

Polish people in London are fighting against discrimination by going on strike outside of Parliament - and donating blood to the NHS.

Eating disorder survivor Jae West invited passing Londoners and tourists to draw hearts on her body (Picture: YouTube)

Eating disorder survivor Jae West stood in her underwear at Piccadilly Circus and asked passersby to draw a heart on her body ‘to support self acceptance’.

It might be called Fine Foods but according to health inspectors this store in Harlesden is one of the dirtiest in the country. (Pic credit: Angela Blake)

If you live in Greenwich, Harlesden, Southall or Highgate, you might, because these neighbourhoods all have shops that feature on a ‘shame list’ of England’s dirtiest premises.

£1.5 billion worth of food is wasted in London every year (Picture: Just Eat It/Peg Leg films)

New London app OLIO lets you share surplus food in your kitchen with neighbours and get delicious cupcakes, salads and dishes in return - almost all for free. London24 spoke to founder Tessa Cook about the app and the ideology behind it.

The hearing took place in the Family Division of the High Court (Photo by Dan Kitwood/Getty Images)

Three girls aged 12, nine and six have been made the subject of a landmark court order to protect them from being ‘cut’.

Ecstasy is at its highest level of use in 10 years (DEA)

The proportion of young people taking ecstasy has soared to the highest level for more than a decade, official figures have shown.

Lewisham Hospital (Picture: PA Images)

A woman from south-east London broke her elbow, went to A&E in Lewisham and then wrote this heartwarming ‘complaint’ letter to NHS staff about her time in hospital.

The Royal Free's air conditioning may have accidently been pumping out hot air instead of cold

Sick and elderly patients said they suffered “sauna-like” conditions while being treated for life-threatening illnesses at the Royal Free Hospital, Hampstead after air conditioning units stopped working yesterday.

Cancer survivor Luna Caden, seven, admires the double helix sculptures

Did you know we share 90 per cent of our genes with a mouse? London now has a DNA inspired art trail which features sculptures by Ai WeiWei and Ted Baker and will raise money for a huge medical research centre.

Condoms are one way of protecting yourself from Chlamydia

Hackney has come out on top for having the most young people with Chlamydia according to a report revealing the growing number of sexually-transmitted infections (STI) in London.

You could end up in hospital if your jeans are too tight (Picture: Claude Truong-Ngoc)

First it was simple hipster mockery, then threats of imprisonment from Isis; now the skinny jeans wearer is facing yet more menace - severe nerve damage.

Would you want to eat anything that had been on these shelves?

The Holloway branch of Poundland has been fined over £12,000 after signs of “widespread rodent activity” were found by Council health officers - including on food shelves.

Maida Vale councillor Rita Begum with Ashley Theophane at the protest (Pic credit: Twitter@cllrritab)

A former British boxing champion flew in from Las Vegas and threw his support behind a fight to stop a sports centre from being demolished in Queen’s Park.

Library photograph of a baby [Photograph courtesy of Beth/Wikipedia Commons]

A woman is fighting a legal battle to use her dead daughter’s frozen eggs to become pregnant with her own grandchild - in a situation that would be a world-first.

Pigeons carry diseases like Chiamdiosis, similar to flu, and Psittacosis, similar to pneumonia  (Photo by Rob Foldy/Getty Images)

A paramedic rushed to the aid of what he believed was a collapsed woman in Southall only to find a dying pigeon.

The London to Dubai plane was forced to turn around (Photo by Peter Macdiarmid/Getty Images)

Hollywood actress Alyssa Milano has hit out at Heathrow Airport security staff after they confiscated breast milk she had pumped for her young baby.

We previously ran an appeal asking the public to report any sightings of Joshua Packman, a young man who was receiving treatment at a mental health unit in Enfield.

Some of the food Chicken Town will offer (Pic: Kickstarter/Chicken Town)

Chicken-loving youngsters in a deprived borough of north London may soon be able to buy healthy fried chicken, if two restaurateurs get the start-up capital they need.

Whitechapel High Street has more unhealthy businesses next door to one another than anywhere else in London (Pic: Getty Images)

A Whitechapel street has won the dubious title of unhealthiest high street in London, according to a public health body.

What is this?

Near You Now

Don't Miss...

Line-Up Events


You'll be stocked up on toiletries  for a while!

Cosmetics, toiletries, vitamins and more.

Read more
You could be splashing the cash at Topshop!

Just imagine what you could do with £1,000 to spend at Topshop.

Read more

Latest Tech News