Lewisham A&E closure proposals ‘unsafe, rushed and unjust’

13:59 08 January 2013

Matthew Kershaw

Matthew Kershaw's recommendations came at the end of a six-week consultation. Picture: Yui Mok/PA Wire

Plans to close and downgrade Lewisham’s emergency and maternity services are “a travesty”, according to one of its consultants.

The hospital will be stripped of its A&E department under proposals today to restructure healthcare services in south east London.

Special administrator Matthew Kershaw today proposed the South London Healthcare NHS Trust is broken up after it racked up debts of £150million.

He recommended A&E services in south east London should only be provided at King’s College Hospital, St Thomas’ Hospital, Queen Elizabeth Hospital and Princess Royal University Hospital.

But Lewisham Hospital is not part of the South London Healthcare NHS Trust.

Consultant physician Dr John O’Donohue said Mr Kershaw had ignored the views of patients and health experts during his six-week consultation.

He said: “Lewisham Hospital is a solvent, successful hospital with a track record for delivering high-quality care.

“This is the first time the government has put in place its ‘Unsustainable Provider Regime’ for failing NHS organizations, and it sets a disturbing precedent.

“If services at a successful and well run hospital like Lewisham are closed due to problems at a neighbouring Trust, then no hospital in London, or the country, is safe.

“These plans are a travesty. They are unsafe, rushed and unjust, but most of all will disadvantage the people of Lewisham, who will have to travel further to already overcrowded neighbouring A&E and maternity units – units which, ironically, have themselves been diverting ambulances and pregnant women to Lewisham in recent days due to lack of capacity.”

Around 15,000 people took part in a march last November to protest against the threat to Lewisham’s A&E unit in November. A further demonstration will take place from the Lewisham Roundabout from noon on January 26.

“No viable alternative option”

The Lewisham Healthcare NHS Trust consultants, and GPs commissioning group also opposed the recommendations.

Lewisham East MP Heidi Alexander also delivered a petition, signed by more than 32,000 people opposing the recommendations, to Downing Street.

A spokesman for the Lewisham Healthcare NHS Trust said they were grateful for the support they had received.

He said: “We do support merging with Queen Elizabeth, which is one of the recommendations.

“However, we do not agree with the TSA’s prescriptive approach to service change, which would result in local emergency services being closed and maternity services being downgraded.

“As a successful organisation, we have said we would like to determine the future of services ourselves, and we would include proper engagement with stakeholders and the public.

He added: “All our services are continuing to run as normal. If the Health Secretary does decide to make changes, it would take place over a three year period, and alternative arrangements would have to be in place first.”

A spokesman for Mr Kershaw said: “The views of local doctors have been extremely important and the trust special administrator (TSA) has sought to modify his recommendations where possible on the basis of clinical feedback.

The challenge was that no viable alternative option was presented.

“To be clear, the consultation was not a vote on whether the recommendations should proceed but an opportunity to validate and refine the options set out in the draft recommendations.

As the TSA has consistently stated, doing nothing is not an option.”

Related articles

Sign up for our news alerts today!

Our editors' picks for the day's top news delivered to your inbox or phone.

Sign up for email alerts Sign up for mobile alerts
1
2 3 4 5 6
7

Latest London Health news

We previously ran an appeal asking the public to report any sightings of Joshua Packman, a young man who was receiving treatment at a mental health unit in Enfield.

Some of the food Chicken Town will offer (Pic: Kickstarter/Chicken Town)

Chicken-loving youngsters in a deprived borough of north London may soon be able to buy healthy fried chicken, if two restaurateurs get the start-up capital they need.

Whitechapel High Street has more unhealthy businesses next door to one another than anywhere else in London (Pic: Getty Images)

A Whitechapel street has won the dubious title of unhealthiest high street in London, according to a public health body.

17:38pm Wharfdale Road looking towards York Way

Angry neighbours complain about traffic chaos

A teenager was stabbed in the bottom near the Emirates, minutes before Arsenal's Champions league game against Monaco

Knife attack - just prior to Champions League game - fifth in borough this month

Abhishek Varma with the bottle of apple juice

Would you drink a bottle of apple juice if you found fungi floating at the top of it?

Dr Dhanuson Dharmasena has been found not guilty of carrying out FGM [Photograph by Jonathan Brady/PA Wire]

The first person in Britain to go on trial for female genital mutilation has been found not guilty.

Pauline Cafferkey, a British nurse who was diagnosed with Ebola on her return from Sierra Leone (Handout/PA Wire)

There are grave concerns for the British nurse who is critical with Ebola after her condition deteriorated over the past few days.

Cockroaches behind refrigeration units

Cockroaches, mice droppings, hobs covered in fat and food left to cool next to bags of rubbish are some of the findings that prompted environmental health officers to shut down this filthy Chinese take-away kitchen.

The woman criticises the anti-abortion campaigners outside the Southwark clinic (Picture: Sunny Hundal/YouTube)

A pregnant woman was filmed criticising anti-abortion protesters outside a south London clinic and it’s awesome.

London Fields Lido has new extended opening hours

London Fields Lido will be open for longer from today after the installation of floodlights.

The £3 pill is for people who drink more than half a bottle of wine or three pints of beer a night  (Photo by Joe Raedle/Getty Images)

It’s something many Londoners have wished for on a Sunday morning. Now a pill which helps dampen the desire to drink alcohol is available to people who drink half a bottle of wine or three pints a night or more.

The church based clinics will test Africans for HIV

Four new HIV testing clinics have been opened in African churches in Southwark, New Cross, Wood Green and Dagenham to combat the high rate the disease among the community.

London Ambulance Service said they were called to a pharmacist in a shopping centre on Stratford's Montfitchet Road [Photograph from Google StreetView]

A shopper in Westfield dialled 999 yesterday - because of trapped wind.

The Ebola virus is deadly in 90 per cent of cases (Cynthia Goldsmith/ Centers for Disease Control and Prevention)

A patient at St George’s Hospital in Tooting who was being tested for ebola does not have the disease, a Public Health England spokesperson has confirmed.

A medical exercise in York before more than 100 army medics were sent to Sierra Leone to help tackle the Ebola crisis.

A suspected case of Ebola was treated at the Homerton Hospital in July, it was revealed by medical directors this morning.

Marcus Campbell (Pic: @Mr Exposed)

Police blocked more than a hundred angry protestors outside Croydon University Hospital last night who were demonstrating over the care of critically ill 22-year-old Marcus Campbell.

British Ebola sufferer William Pooley is returning to the country where he caught the disease [Picture: Andrew Matthews]

The Ebola survivor who was treated at the Royal Free Hospital has flown back to the country where he caught the deadly virus.

Boris Johnson has been urged to ban smoking in open public spaces in London like Trafalgar Square (Photo by Dan Kitwood/Getty Images)

Boris Johnson has been urged to ban smoking in thousands of acres of parkland and public open spaces in London like Trafalgar Square and Parliament Square.

Dom Stark tweeted this photo of the 'maternity ward' [Photograph courtesy of @LDN_ambulance]

If you hate being stuck in gridlock, spare a thought for the poor woman who gave birth on the side of the North Circular on Monday.

Kids Company founder Camila Batmanghelidjh in discussion with the Prime Minister (Photo by Oli Scarff/Getty Images)

Child poverty has become such a problem in the capital that many parents go without food to feed their children, and some turn to desperate measures.

William Pooley recovered at this specialist unit at the Royal Free (Jonathan Brady/PA Wire)

The first Briton known to have caught the deadly Ebola virus in the current outbreak has been released from north London’s Royal Free Hospital.

Dr. Michael Jacobs, clinical lead in Infectious Diseases at the Royal Free Hospital, is in charge of treating the Ebola patient. Picture: Stefan Rousseau

The first Briton to contract the deadly Ebola virus is being treated with experimental new drug ZMapp, doctors at the Royal Free have said.

Senior Matron Breda Athan demonstrates the use of a high level isolation apparatus in the High Secure Infectious Disease Unit at The Royal Free Hospital, Hampstead (Jonathan Brady/PA Wire)

British Ebola victim William Pooley will be kept in strict isolation at the Royal Free hospital in Hampstead, behind plastic sheeting for weeks while doctors battle to save his life, experts have said.

Kieran Sorkin with his new set of ears after surgery at Great Ormond Street Hospital (Picture: John Stillwell/PA Wire)

Not many children dream of having a ‘big pair of ears’, but for one nine-year-old who was born without a pair his wish has come true after pioneering surgery at Great Ormond Street Hospital.

What is this?

Near You Now

Don't Miss...

Competitions

Munch on a tasy three course dinner at The Refinery!

“Where to go for a drink near Great Portland Street?” was previously met with blank expressions and shrugs for those local to the area, not anymore, thanks to the opening of The Refinery at Regent’s Place, the eighth bar and restaurant from hugely-successful group Drake & Morgan.

Read more