The five best Sherlock conspiracy theories as fans get ready to find out how he really faked his own death

14:01 23 December 2013

How did he do it? Fans have been speculating how Sherlock faked his own death since the end of series two. Picture: PA Photo/BBC/Hartswood Films/Robert Viglasky.

How did he do it? Fans have been speculating how Sherlock faked his own death since the end of series two. Picture: PA Photo/BBC/Hartswood Films/Robert Viglasky.

The great mystery of how Sherlock survived his ‘fatal’ fall in the last episode will finally be solved when the new series starts on New Year’s Day, but if you cant wait that long here are some of the internet’s best conspiracies of how the detective did it.

The big reveal is planned for the new episode due to air on New Year's Day. Picture: PA Photo/BBC/Hartswood Films/Robert Viglasky.The big reveal is planned for the new episode due to air on New Year's Day. Picture: PA Photo/BBC/Hartswood Films/Robert Viglasky.

At the end of The Reichenbach Fall, Benedict Cumberbatch’s character appears to drop to his death from the roof of St Bartholomew’s Hospital, only to appear out of the shadows as Watson and Mrs Hudson visit his grave.

Ever since viewers have been speculating about how he managed to pull the hoax off, with fans pouring over the footage for clues.

Even the show’s other star, Martin Freeman, is keeping tight-lipped on what really happened.

“You know that ultimately people don’t want to hear it,” he says. “They’d much rather discover it, and it’s just more fun if you see it than if I blow it for you.”

Did Sherlock's brother Mycroft Holmes help him fake his death? Picture: PA Photo/BBC/Hartswood Films/Robert Viglasky.Did Sherlock's brother Mycroft Holmes help him fake his death? Picture: PA Photo/BBC/Hartswood Films/Robert Viglasky.

But here are some of the best theories people have come up with:

Rubbish truck theory

The rubbish truck that was parked in front of the building Holmes fell from cushioned his fall.

Cyclist theory

The cyclist who knocked Watson over as he dashed to help Holmes was actually one of a network of homeless people he pays to provide him with information. He arranged the whole thing so Watson missed the moment he hit the ground, giving him time to escape and a body double to take his place.

Medicine theory

Holmes’s brother, Mycroft, plied the detective with fake blood and medicine to give the appearance of death, and paid people to pose as fake surgeons and pronounce him dead.

Mask theory

Holmes used his recently-deceased nemesis Moriarty’s body to help him fake his fall, covering his face with a latex ‘Sherlock’ mask before dropping him from the roof.

Rubber ball theory

During the last episode of series two, Holmes was seen playing with a rubber ball. Theorists believe he used a sleight of hand trick, whereby squeezing the rubber ball in his palm temporarily stopped his pulse so that he appeared dead.

The new series of Sherlock starts on BBC One on New Years Day, but a special mini-episode will be available from Christmas Eve.

Sign up for our news alerts today!

Our editors' picks for the day's top news delivered to your inbox or phone.

Sign up for email alerts Sign up for mobile alerts
1
2 3 4 5 6
7

Christmas Galleries

14th January 1957:  A bush-baby getting his winter dose of cod liver oil at London Zoo (Photo by William Vanderson/Fox Photos/Getty Images)

Think you’ve got it tough in winter? These animals take it all in their stride...

Brazilians take pictures while riding on a boat to view the world's largest floating Christmas tree on December 21, 2014 in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. The tree is 85-meters tall and features over 3 million light bulbs.  (Photo by Mario Tama/Getty Images)

London does Christmas brilliantly...but as these amazing pictures show, so does the rest of the world. What do you think? Has London been top trumped?

30th November 1955:  Christmas decorations in Regent Street, London, consisting mainly of snow crystal stars made of aluminium to give the effect of a snowstorm.  (Photo by Keystone/Getty Images)

Is London ever more atmospheric than when it’s covered in a dusting of crisp white snow?

Entertainment

(Graphic: Zoah Hedges-Stocks)

Okay, so the holidays are over, but the new year doesn’t have to be all about teetotal resolutions and dreary weather. Here are some things to look forward to in January 2016.

We'ev got lots of New Year's Eve in London ideas (Photo by Bruno Vincent/Getty Images)

There are lots of quirky, classy and cheap things to do this New Year’s Eve in London. Here, we round up the best nights out for all budgets and tastes.

The luxurious bar and restaurant at the top of the Gherkin is not normally open to the public (Photo: Daniel Berehulak/Getty Images)

There’s a swanky bar at the top of the Gherkin, but as it’s a private members’ club, it’s not normally open to Joe Public.